10 Restaurants to Try in The Bahamas

Picture this: you're vacationing in The Bahamas, lounging in the sun, relaxing by the pool, and swimming in the crystal clear blue ocean. What could make life any better? A delicious, flavour-filled meal. Thankfully, Nassau & Paradise Island boast some of the best fine and casual dining options in the Caribbean. Now the question is, where to go? To help narrow your decision, we’ve curated a list of must-try restaurants in the area. Here are ten restaurants for you to indulge in the flavours of Paradise.

Seafire Steakhouse

Located at Atlantis Paradise Island, Seafire Steakhouse’s rich flavours of smoked, seared, and grilled dishes craft a delightful atmosphere for the perfect meal. Enjoy mouthwatering dishes like lemon-pepper tuna, coriander-crusted beef carpaccio, sweet Bahamian lobster tails, and praline chocolate cake. To top it off, their recipe blend of “serious cocktails” makes Seafire Steakhouse a perfect place for pre, during, and after-dinner drinks.

FIELDTRIP

Set in more of a laid-back yet stylish atmosphere at Atlantis Paradise Island, award-winning chef JJ Johnson’s restaurant FIELDTRIP is the perfect place to enjoy a casual dining experience while soaking in island vibes. As strong advocates for sustainability, they offer a menu of rice bowls carefully prepared with the finest local ingredients, ensuring a proper made-to-order experience. 

Butch's Island Chop House

If you’re looking for a delicious dinner meal a cut above the rest, Butch’s Island Chop House is the place. Located at Sandals Royal Bahamian All-Inclusive, they serve hand-cut steaks, fish fillets, and seafood cooked to your specifications, seasoned to perfection, and paired with exquisite sides and flavorful sauces. Named after Gordon “Butch” Stewert, the founder of Sandals Resorts, the experience of unparalleled quality and luxury ambience will undoubtedly have you coming back for more.

Streetbird on the Beach

When it comes to anything chicken, Streetbird on the Beach in Baha Mar should be your go-to in Nassau & Paradise Island. A casual dining concept by Marcus Samuelsson, Streetbird combines the flavours of Harlem with a Caribbean twist. Whether you like it spicy or sweet, Streetbird delivers it hot and fresh which will have you coming back for more. Make sure to try some of their famous dishes, such as Calypso Conch Fritters, Escovitch Chicken, or Plantain Waffles.

Fi'lia

Italian food connoisseur? Look no further. Nestled in SLS Baha Mar, Fi’lia boasts an authentic Italian menu with a modern twist. Surround yourself in their warm and inviting atmosphere while enjoying signature dishes such as rustic wood-fired oven pizzas, freshly-tossed Caesar salad with fragrant garlic croutons, or a plate piled high with spaghetti or fettuccine. The best part? They are family-friendly, and kids under five eat for free!

OIA Restaurant

At OIA, be prepared to adventure on a culinary journey full of trendy Mediterranean and Asian flair with the perfect blend of tropical energy. Indulge in an unforgettable dining experience of locally sourced ingredients at this Goldwynn Resort & Residences restaurant, be it a beautifully crafted breakfast or a romantic dinner in Paradise. OIA’s bold and creative approach is a must-see in The Bahamas. Being the first of its kind in Nassau, OIA uses a fusion of flavors influenced by Mediterranean specialties and Peruvian favorites, modeled by Japanese techniques. Oh, and remember to pair your meal with one of their excellently crafted classic cocktails!

Paranza

Nestled in Atlantis Paradise Island, Paranza is an innovative restaurant that specializes in fresh, high-quality seafood. Drawing inspiration from Italy’s coastline and being a vibrant tribute to the country, Paranza brings the essence of the Mediterranean to life through Chef White’s masterful creativity. The blend of modern sophistication and authenticity creates the atmosphere for a dining experience like no other.

La Plume

Combining a harmonious blend of exquisite Parisian-style dishes and vibrant flavours of the Caribbean, La Plume is the perfect restaurant to experience the elegance of French cuisine during your Nassau & Paradise Island vacation. Join them at Sandals Royal Bahamian All-Inclusive for a delicious breakfast of smoked salmon benedict, or enjoy the artfully crafted cordon bleu de poulet for dinner. The restaurant’s chic decor and atmosphere sets the perfect stage for a memorable meal in Paradise.

Be Sure to Pack Your Appetite

Delicious dining is one of the most important parts of an unforgettable vacation, and here in Paradise, there’s plenty to sample on the menu! Whether you’re a serious foodie or just looking to fuel your fun, Nassau & Paradise Island has you covered. 

Start planning your trip today, and be sure to check out our full list of dining options in the area.